Thursday, December 1, 2022

Chocolate Pudding Pie

I randomly came across this recipe right before Thanksgiving and decided to give it a try and bring it with us to my parents house.  IT TURNED OUT SO GOOD and it was super simple to make.  We couldn't get enough and I already have a second one chilling in my refrigerator right now.  I didn't snap a pic of the pie as a whole, so take this slice pic as my promise that it is INCREDIBLE!

Here's What You'll Need...
- 1 oreo pie crust
- Two 9-oz boxes of instant chocolate pudding mix
- 1 pint half and half
- 1 tub cool whip (you can use the regular size tub... all my store had was the giant one)
- chocolate to use for shavings

Here's What You'll Do...
- Pour the half and half into the two packages of pudding mix and whisk until combined.  I panicked a little bit because mine looked a little thick and like all the mix didn't dissolve BUT IT WAS FINE!  Refrigerate it for about 5 minutes so it can set a bit.

- Put half of the pudding mixture into the crust

- Mix half the tub (the regular size tub not the small one) into the remaining half of the pudding mixture and stir with a wooden spoon until it's combined.  

- Spread the cool whip/pudding mixture on the first layer and then top the whole thing with cool whip and sprinkle on some chocolate shavings.  

- Chill for about 4 hours (or overnight), cut and serve chilled.

I really can't even explain how delish this was.  I was skeptical but it was PERFECTION!  Make this for Christmas! Make this for this weekend!  Make it NOW and thank me later ;)

HAPPY Thursday, friends!!!


  1. This sounds good and so easy! I'll be trying this out for Christmas for sure.

  2. add some peppermint extract or Andes mints to it for a festive Holiday pie!

  3. Do you mean 2) 3.9 oz puddings? I actually used 2) 3.9 & 2 bigger boxes to equal 2 9 oz & it was really rubbery. haha!


Blog design by Get Polished | Copyright 2016